P0ISSUED_AWAITING_OWNERGate impact · BC-06 -> G-PH6A
OER-02 — BC-06 — Critical Control Operating Model
Obtain the competent owner decision for the governing Critical Control operating model applicable to CV-07.
Recipient role
Corporate ES&H / Critical Control Authority
Competent authority status
CLAIMED_BY_DESIGN_NOT_CONFIRMED_BY_OWNER
Scope
Critical Control governance applicable to CV-07 pre-start decisions.
Request version
OER-02-REV1
Panel A · Design Position — READ ONLY (baseline frozen)
Design position
Two dispositions remain open: PATH_A (authoritative corporate Critical Control source) and PATH_B (governed federated Critical Control model). Forwood Safety remains a CANDIDATE system/source until confirmed by competent authority. Owner may also respond ALTERNATIVE_MODEL_REQUIRED or NOT_COMPETENT_TO_DECIDE.
Design recommendation
Design recommendation is PATH_B. Recommendation != Owner Decision; PATH_B is not elected and confers no closure.
Prohibitions
- · Candidate source may not be promoted to authoritative source without owner evidence
- · Path B may never be selected merely to facilitate closure
- · Software may enforce a transaction HOLD; it SHALL NOT autonomously command a physical work stoppage absent an approved operational rule and competent human authority
Design Recommendation != Operational Decision. This panel confers no closure.
Panel B · Competent Owner Response
Editable by: Corporate ES&H / Critical Control Authority only. This panel is never populated automatically, by design authority, or by AI.
AWAITING_OWNERResponses received · 0
| Required decision | Owner value | State |
|---|---|---|
| OwnerDisposition (PATH_A | PATH_B | ALTERNATIVE_MODEL_REQUIRED | NOT_COMPETENT_TO_DECIDE) | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| ConfirmedSource | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| SemanticAuthority | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| CriticalControlOwner | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| WriteAuthority | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| VerificationAuthority | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| DecisionAuthority | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| DelegationAuthority | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| RevocationAuthority | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| ValidityRule | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| ChangePropagationRule | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| FieldConflictBehaviour | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| EscalationAuthority | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| EvidenceCustody | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
| ExceptionBehaviour | NOT_PROVIDED — AWAITING_OWNER | AWAITING_OWNER |
Panel C · Independent Assurance Use Only
Editable by: Independent Assurance only. A path election recorded without governance attributes is INCONCLUSIVE_EVIDENCE, not closure.
AWAITING_OWNERNOT_EVALUABLE_NO_EVIDENCEClosureSufficiency · INSUFFICIENT
| Check | Question | Result |
|---|---|---|
| C1 · Authenticity | Is the artefact genuinely from the claimed source and unaltered? | NOT_EVALUABLE_NO_EVIDENCE |
| C2 · Authority | Does the submitter hold the competent authority claimed for this decision? | NOT_EVALUABLE_NO_EVIDENCE |
| C3 · ScopeFit | Does the artefact cover the CV-07 pilot scope actually required? | NOT_EVALUABLE_NO_EVIDENCE |
| C4 · VersionValidity | Is the artefact the governing version at evaluation time? | NOT_EVALUABLE_NO_EVIDENCE |
| C5 · TemporalValidity | Is the fact effective and unexpired at DecisionTime? | NOT_EVALUABLE_NO_EVIDENCE |
| C6 · ContradictionStatus | Does it contradict any other admitted evidence item? | NOT_EVALUABLE_NO_EVIDENCE |
| C7 · ClosureRelevance | Does it materially bear on the stated closure predicate? | NOT_EVALUABLE_NO_EVIDENCE |
Admission = Authenticity AND Authority AND ScopeFit AND VersionValidity AND TemporalValidity AND ContradictionClear AND ClosureRelevant. No weighted scoring, no averaging, no compensating controls. One material failure prevents admission. ClosureSufficiency (INSUFFICIENT | SUFFICIENT_FOR_RETEST | SUFFICIENT_FOR_CLOSURE) is evaluated separately — Admission != Closure.
Enabled only for Independent Assurance once evidence existsPredicates · Closure Predicates & Safe Behaviour
OPENCRITICAL_CONTROL_OPERATING_MODEL = OWNER_VALIDATED
OPENCURRENT_CRITICAL_CONTROL_STATE_CAN_BE_RECONSTRUCTED_FROM_GOVERNED_SOURCE_AND_FIELD_EVIDENCE = TRUE
- · CriticalControlGovernance = UNRESOLVED => PILOT BLOCKER
- · CriticalControlVerified = FALSE => deterministic material transaction state = HOLD
Related BC / EXT
BC-06