Phase 6A — Pre-Execution Readiness Closure (Rev.3)
Phase 6A has been executed as a readiness determination against the frozen Pilot Definition Baseline. No prerequisite has been converted into an evidence-backed operational state: every enterprise interface remains NOT_YET_VALIDATED, enterprise identity remains unresolved, the Pilot-scope lifecycle authority decisions (ADR-15 / ADR-17) remain open, mandatory stewardship roles remain unstaffed, CA-04 classification remains unresolved, field prerequisites are unconfirmed, and BEFORE measurement has not started prospectively. Critical Control participation remains SIMULATED and has not been rescoped by competent authority. Under the Phase 6A GO criteria, all ten gates fail; the disposition is therefore HOLD.
The Phase 6 Pilot Definition Baseline is reproduced unchanged. No journey, metric, protocol or scope element has been altered, softened or removed. No change was made to improve the likelihood of a Pilot PASS.
A · Executive summary — prohibited claims at this stage
- Executing any of the twenty Pilot journeys
- Claiming BEFORE/AFTER results, savings or adoption outcomes
- Treating a simulated Critical Control journey as production-level integration evidence
- Reconstructing a BEFORE baseline retrospectively
- Executing Phase 6B
Evidence GC-01…GC-05 and the field/measurement prerequisites, then re-run Phase 6A. Phase 6B begins only after a formal GO — CONTROLLED PILOT EXECUTION AUTHORIZED.
§2 · Frozen Pilot Definition Baseline — integrity check
Any requested change to the frozen Pilot Definition must be classified and logged before it is applied. Changes must never be made to improve the likelihood of a Pilot PASS. Logged change requests: 0.
C · Enterprise Interface Validation Register (GC-01)
PilotObject: Safety Document, Permit, Isolation, Work Pack state
AuthorityClass: SOURCE_MASTER (authorization control)
Mechanism: UNKNOWN — no interface catalogue supplied; API existence not evidenced.
Read / Write / Event: NOT_DEMONSTRATED · PROHIBITED for pilot (no write-back authorized) · NOT_DEMONSTRATED
VersionBehaviour: UNDEFINED — decision pinning cannot be evidenced.
FailureBehaviour: Fail-closed by design: unmapped/unavailable state ⇒ HOLD.
EvidenceOfValidation: NONE — no validation artefact produced by the source system owner.
SupportOwner: UNASSIGNED
PilotObject: Controlled document, revision, transmittal
AuthorityClass: SOURCE_MASTER (document control)
Mechanism: UNKNOWN — manual copy is not an interface.
Read / Write / Event: NOT_DEMONSTRATED · PROHIBITED · NOT_DEMONSTRATED
VersionBehaviour: Revision pinning designed, not demonstrated.
FailureBehaviour: Unpinnable revision ⇒ condition invalid ⇒ HOLD.
EvidenceOfValidation: NONE — no validation artefact produced by the source system owner.
SupportOwner: UNASSIGNED
PilotObject: Activity, lookahead window, planned execution date
AuthorityClass: SOURCE_MASTER (schedule)
Mechanism: UNKNOWN — periodic export assumed, not evidenced.
Read / Write / Event: NOT_DEMONSTRATED · PROHIBITED · NOT_DEMONSTRATED
VersionBehaviour: Snapshot identity required for Forecast Readiness; undemonstrated.
FailureBehaviour: Stale schedule ⇒ forecast marked INVALID, never optimistic.
EvidenceOfValidation: NONE — no validation artefact produced by the source system owner.
SupportOwner: UNASSIGNED
PilotObject: Life-Critical verification / critical control confirmation
AuthorityClass: SOURCE_MASTER (non-compensable control)
Mechanism: None — prototype simulation only.
Read / Write / Event: SIMULATED · PROHIBITED · NONE
VersionBehaviour: N/A
FailureBehaviour: Absent real control evidence ⇒ non-compensable failure ⇒ STOP.
EvidenceOfValidation: NONE — no validation artefact produced by the source system owner.
SupportOwner: UNASSIGNED
PilotObject: Competency validity, expiry
AuthorityClass: SOURCE_MASTER (competency)
Mechanism: UNKNOWN
Read / Write / Event: NOT_DEMONSTRATED · PROHIBITED · NOT_DEMONSTRATED
VersionBehaviour: Expiry timestamps required for forecast; unevidenced.
FailureBehaviour: Unknown validity ⇒ treated as invalid (fail-closed).
EvidenceOfValidation: NONE — no validation artefact produced by the source system owner.
SupportOwner: UNASSIGNED
PilotObject: Identity, role, delegation, authority expiry
AuthorityClass: SOURCE_MASTER (identity)
Mechanism: UNKNOWN — federation protocol not confirmed.
Read / Write / Event: NOT_DEMONSTRATED · PROHIBITED · NOT_DEMONSTRATED
VersionBehaviour: N/A
FailureBehaviour: Unresolved identity ⇒ no authorization action offered.
EvidenceOfValidation: NONE — no validation artefact produced by the source system owner.
SupportOwner: UNASSIGNED
- An interface is not integrated because its data can be manually copied.
- No API is assumed to exist; capability must be demonstrated by the source system owner.
- Any interface required by a mandatory Pilot decision must hold a validated participation mode before GO.
F · Critical Control participation decision
Current classification: SIMULATED
Path A: A real governed Critical Control source participates with evidence-backed authority and interface behaviour.
Path B: Competent governance formally rescopes the Life-Critical journey and classifies it SIMULATED_ONLY / NON_ACCEPTANCE_EVIDENCE.
Decision taken: NONE — neither Path A nor Path B has been exercised by competent authority.
Consequence: The Life-Critical Pilot journey is NOT EXECUTABLE as Pilot evidence. It must not be silently weakened, and a simulated journey cannot support any claim of production-level Critical Control integration.
D · IAM / Authority readiness (GC-02)
Requirement: Authenticated enterprise identity resolvable to one accountable person per Pilot actor.
Evidence: None — prototype uses a declared session identity.
Requirement: Roles resolved server-side from an authoritative source.
Evidence: None — roles are client-selected in the prototype.
Requirement: Authority bounded to the Pilot project.
Evidence: Designed only.
Requirement: Authority bounded to AREA-3100 / CV-07.
Evidence: Designed only.
Requirement: Authority bounded to discipline and activity class.
Evidence: Designed only.
Requirement: Authority bounded by risk class; Life-Critical requires elevated authority.
Evidence: Designed only.
Requirement: Delegation issued, bounded, recorded, revocable.
Evidence: Prototype model exists; no enterprise-backed delegation.
Requirement: Expiry enforced at decision time; expired authority denies.
Evidence: Enforced in prototype only.
Requirement: Denials produce attributable evidence; UI hiding is not enforcement.
Evidence: Prototype records denials; no enterprise enforcement point.
Requirement: Reconstructable who / what / when / on-what-basis.
Evidence: Prototype evidence chain only.
UI hiding is not accepted as authority enforcement. No Pilot journey involving real authorization may execute with unresolved identity.
GC-03 · Pilot authority & lifecycle (ADR-15 / ADR-17)
LifecycleOwner: UNRESOLVED — ADR-15 open
StateOwner: UNRESOLVED
TransitionAuthority: UNRESOLVED — candidate: discipline supervisor within Location scope
ValidTransition: PLANNED → READY_FOR_EXECUTION only when all mandatory conditions are VALID and applicable.
InvalidTransition: Any transition to READY with an open non-compensable failure; any auto-advance on timeout.
EvidenceRequired: Pinned source versions, applicability decision, human confirmation with attribution.
DelegationRule: Bounded, time-limited, recorded; never implicit.
AuthorityUnavailable: Fail-closed: remain at current state, surface HOLD; never auto-advance.
LifecycleOwner: UNRESOLVED — ADR-17 open
StateOwner: UNRESOLVED
TransitionAuthority: UNRESOLVED
ValidTransition: Only with an in-date authorization and an owning discipline authority.
InvalidTransition: Continuation past expiry; inheritance across Location handover.
EvidenceRequired: Authorization record, expiry, removal plan.
DelegationRule: Not delegable below the authorizing discipline authority.
AuthorityUnavailable: STOP for dependent work.
LifecycleOwner: ADR-14 Location Steward (role defined, unstaffed)
StateOwner: Location Steward
TransitionAuthority: Location Steward with ES&H concurrence for SIMOPS-affecting change
ValidTransition: Context persists across discipline handover; authorization never inherits.
InvalidTransition: Reusing a prior discipline's authorization for a new discipline.
EvidenceRequired: Re-evaluated applicability set with USED / REVALIDATED / RENEWED / REJECTED per condition.
DelegationRule: Backup steward only, named in advance.
AuthorityUnavailable: DISABLED_SAFE for the Location.
Only lifecycle/authority decisions required by CV-07 are in scope. Broader ADR questions remain deliberately open rather than being closed by convenience. HOLD, STOP and fail-closed behaviour are preserved unchanged.
E · Stewardship Assignment Register (GC-04)
NamedAssignment: UNASSIGNED — no named person nominated by resourcing authority.
Authority: Owns Location context, concurrency set, SIMOPS declaration.
Availability: Required across all Pilot shifts — not confirmed.
Backup: None named.
Escalation: Undefined.
NamedAssignment: UNASSIGNED — no named person nominated by resourcing authority.
Authority: Owns source-to-canonical mapping and unmapped-state exceptions.
Availability: Not confirmed.
Backup: None named.
Escalation: Undefined.
NamedAssignment: UNASSIGNED — no named person nominated by resourcing authority.
Authority: Owns classification of non-compensable controls; no technical default may substitute.
Availability: Not confirmed.
Backup: None named.
Escalation: Undefined.
NamedAssignment: UNASSIGNED — no named person nominated by resourcing authority.
Authority: Owns Pilot scope and change classification.
Availability: Not confirmed.
Backup: None named.
Escalation: Undefined.
NamedAssignment: UNASSIGNED — no named person nominated by resourcing authority.
Authority: Owns interface failure response within the Pilot window.
Availability: Not confirmed.
Backup: None named.
Escalation: Undefined.
NamedAssignment: UNASSIGNED — no named person nominated by resourcing authority.
Authority: First-line field support for Pilot users.
Availability: Not confirmed.
Backup: None named.
Escalation: Undefined.
NamedAssignment: UNASSIGNED — no named person nominated by resourcing authority.
Authority: Owns funded training and adoption workstream.
Availability: Unfunded.
Backup: None named.
Escalation: Undefined.
- A role may be organizationally assigned to a person for Pilot execution, but the architecture remains role-based.
- Vacancy in a mandatory role ⇒ DISABLED_SAFE for the dependent capability; the Location issues no readiness decision.
§8 · Design-team-withdrawn test readiness
NormalSupportPath: Field user → Operational Support → Location Steward (context) or Federation Mapping Steward (source/mapping) → Rule Governance for classification questions.
EscalationPath: Unresolved within the shift → Product Ownership → Project governance. Safety-affecting ambiguity escalates immediately to ES&H authority and the work remains on HOLD.
EmergencyExceptionRule: Design-team involvement is permitted only for a defect that prevents fail-closed behaviour, must be logged as a stewardship-sustainability observation, and never counts as normal support.
Design team excluded activities
- Resolving Location mapping exceptions
- Deciding applicability or compensability questions
- Interpreting readiness verdicts for field users
- Repairing source-state exceptions
- Answering evidence-reconstruction requests
- Direct field user support
GC-05 · Governed classification / retention (CA-04)
Compensability: Fails closed as NON_COMPENSABLE pending governance decision.
Retention: UNRESOLVED — statutory horizon not confirmed for the Pilot jurisdiction.
AuthorityBasis: ADR-16 rule governance + legal/records
ApprovedBy: NONE · EffectiveFrom — · EvidenceRef NONE
Compensability: Fails closed as NON_COMPENSABLE.
Retention: UNRESOLVED
AuthorityBasis: ES&H authority
ApprovedBy: NONE · EffectiveFrom — · EvidenceRef NONE
Compensability: Fails closed as NON_COMPENSABLE for Life-Critical activity.
Retention: UNRESOLVED
AuthorityBasis: Training governance
ApprovedBy: NONE · EffectiveFrom — · EvidenceRef NONE
Compensability: Not applicable (record class), but retention is mandatory for reconstruction.
Retention: UNRESOLVED
AuthorityBasis: Legal / records governance
ApprovedBy: NONE · EffectiveFrom — · EvidenceRef NONE
No technical default may decide compensability. Where a mandatory classification is unresolved, the system records CLASSIFICATION_UNRESOLVED and fails closed.
G · Field Prerequisite Register
Requirement: Permitted physical and observational access across the Pilot window.
Evidence: None obtained.
Owner: Site leadership
Requirement: Named mechanical, electrical and instrumentation crews committed to Pilot journeys.
Evidence: None obtained.
Owner: Construction management
Requirement: Supervisors available and briefed for each discipline.
Evidence: None obtained.
Owner: Discipline superintendents
Requirement: Live 2–3 week lookahead for the CV-07 corridor.
Evidence: None obtained (P6 NOT_CONNECTED).
Owner: Project Controls
Requirement: Real concurrent Job Cards planned within the corridor.
Evidence: None obtained.
Owner: Work Control
Requirement: Tag / system / energy-state context for the corridor.
Evidence: None obtained.
Owner: Commissioning
Requirement: Agreed windows that do not disturb mandatory production/control processes.
Evidence: None obtained.
Owner: Site leadership
Requirement: Coverage across the shifts in which journeys occur.
Evidence: None obtained.
Owner: Construction management
Requirement: Consented observation, recording and privacy protocol.
Evidence: None obtained.
Owner: Product Ownership + IR
Requirement: Written confirmation the Pilot cannot disrupt mandatory production/control processes.
Evidence: None obtained.
Owner: Operations authority
H · BEFORE Measurement Readiness — twelve frozen metrics
Start → End: Supervisor begins readiness check. → Readiness conclusion reached.
Source / Method: Field observation · Timed observation
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · Requires field access — NOT_AVAILABLE.
ExclusionRule: Exclude interruptions unrelated to readiness.
Start → End: Readiness check begins. → Binding blocker named correctly.
Source / Method: Field observation · Timed observation
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE
ExclusionRule: Exclude cases with no blocker.
Start → End: Check begins. → Decision reached.
Source / Method: Field observation · Count
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE
ExclusionRule: Exclude systems opened for unrelated work.
Start → End: Shift start. → Shift end.
Source / Method: Field observation · Count
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE
ExclusionRule: Exclude corrections of user error.
Start → End: Search begins. → Correct revision confirmed.
Source / Method: Field observation · Timed observation
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE (Aconex NOT_CONNECTED).
ExclusionRule: Exclude searches for non-mandatory documents.
Start → End: Crew arrives at work front. → Work starts or is aborted.
Source / Method: Work Control records · Ratio
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE — source interface not validated.
ExclusionRule: Exclude weather-only stand-downs.
Start → End: Crew mobilises. → Work abandoned before start.
Source / Method: Supervisor log · Count
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE — source interface not validated.
ExclusionRule: Exclude reassignments not caused by readiness.
Start → End: Condition becomes invalid. → Owner becomes aware.
Source / Method: Source timestamps · Interval
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE — source interface not validated.
ExclusionRule: Exclude conditions never relevant to planned work.
Start → End: Lookahead publication. → Execution day.
Source / Method: Planning records · Count
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE — source interface not validated.
ExclusionRule: Exclude conflicts outside the corridor.
Start → End: Work executed. → Rework raised.
Source / Method: Quality records · Count + attribution
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE — source interface not validated.
ExclusionRule: Exclude design-change rework.
Start → End: Evidence request raised. → Complete basis assembled.
Source / Method: Audit exercise · Timed exercise
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE — source interface not validated.
ExclusionRule: Exclude requests outside the corridor.
Start → End: Authorization requested. → Decision issued or refused.
Source / Method: Work Control records · Count
Owner / Availability: UNASSIGNED · NOT_AVAILABLE — source interface not validated.
ExclusionRule: Exclude escalations caused by absence unrelated to the Pilot.
The twelve approved BEFORE metrics remain unchanged. Measurement must begin prospectively; a baseline must never be reconstructed retrospectively after the Pilot has begun.
I · Offline / Reconciliation Readiness
Requirement: Field capture continues without connectivity, marked as capture only.
Demonstrated: Prototype behaviour only; no Pilot device build exists.
Requirement: Every offline record pins the source versions it was based on.
Demonstrated: Designed; not demonstrated on Pilot mechanism.
Requirement: Queued items cannot be edited to appear authorized.
Demonstrated: Designed; not demonstrated.
Requirement: Deterministic resynchronisation on reconnect.
Demonstrated: Not demonstrated.
Requirement: Base-version drift detected and surfaced, never auto-merged.
Demonstrated: Not demonstrated.
Requirement: Human reconciliation with attribution.
Demonstrated: Not demonstrated.
Requirement: SERVICE_RESTORED is distinguished from OPERATIONALLY_RECOVERED.
Demonstrated: Not demonstrated.
OFFLINE NEVER AUTHORIZES.
The offline Pilot journey is classified NOT_EXECUTABLE_IN_CURRENT_PILOT. Successful offline behaviour will not be simulated and presented as Pilot evidence.
§13 · Phase 6A Readiness Register
RequiredEvidence: Per-source validated participation mode with owner-issued evidence artefact.
EvidenceObtained: None (6 of 6 sources unvalidated).
Owner: Enterprise system owners + Integration governance
ResidualRisk: Decisions would rest on unproven source behaviour — false READY risk.
Disposition: HOLD until each mandatory-decision source holds a validated participation mode.
RequiredEvidence: Server-side identity, role, scope, delegation and expiry enforcement with denial evidence.
EvidenceObtained: None — prototype identity only.
Owner: Enterprise IAM owner + ES&H
ResidualRisk: Unattributable authorization; audit reconstruction would fail.
Disposition: HOLD — no real authorization journey may execute.
RequiredEvidence: Lifecycle and transition authority resolved for Job Card and Temporary Modification in CV-07.
EvidenceObtained: None — both objects UNRESOLVED.
Owner: Enterprise Work Control authority
ResidualRisk: State changes without an accountable owner.
Disposition: HOLD or formally reduce Pilot scope in writing.
RequiredEvidence: Named assignment, authority, availability, backup and escalation for 7 roles.
EvidenceObtained: None — all roles unstaffed; P3-TRN-01 unfunded.
Owner: Project / site leadership
ResidualRisk: Design-team dependency would be structurally guaranteed.
Disposition: HOLD — dependent capabilities remain DISABLED_SAFE.
RequiredEvidence: Approved classification, compensability and retention per evidence class.
EvidenceObtained: None — all four entries CLASSIFICATION_UNRESOLVED.
Owner: Legal / records governance + ES&H
ResidualRisk: Compensability decided by technical default — constitutional violation.
Disposition: HOLD and fail closed where materially required.
RequiredEvidence: Real governed participation, or a written rescope to SIMULATED_ONLY / NON_ACCEPTANCE_EVIDENCE.
EvidenceObtained: None — remains SIMULATED with no governance decision.
Owner: Critical Control functional owner
ResidualRisk: Simulated control mistaken for real integration evidence.
Disposition: HOLD — Life-Critical journey not executable as evidence.
RequiredEvidence: Support and escalation paths staffed and exercised without design-team involvement.
EvidenceObtained: None — no organizational roles to withdraw from.
Owner: Operational Support + Product Ownership
ResidualRisk: Sustainability result would be predetermined and meaningless.
Disposition: HOLD until GC-04 is closed.
RequiredEvidence: Access, crews, supervision, lookahead, Job Cards, equipment context, windows, shifts, observation protocol, non-disruption confirmation.
EvidenceObtained: None of 10 confirmed.
Owner: Site leadership
ResidualRisk: Pilot could disturb mandatory production/control processes.
Disposition: HOLD.
RequiredEvidence: Twelve metrics instrumented, owned and capturing prospectively before activation.
EvidenceObtained: None — 12 of 12 NOT_READY, no owners assigned.
Owner: Project Controls + Product Ownership
ResidualRisk: Retrospective baseline reconstruction would invalidate all value claims.
Disposition: HOLD — start prospective capture first.
RequiredEvidence: Demonstrated capture, base-version pinning, immutable queue, conflict detection, reconciliation and recovery verification.
EvidenceObtained: None demonstrated on a Pilot mechanism.
Owner: Integration Support + Product Ownership
ResidualRisk: Simulated success could mask an unauthorized offline authorization path.
Disposition: Offline journey classified NOT_EXECUTABLE_IN_CURRENT_PILOT.
RequiredEvidence: Baseline reproduced unchanged; any change classified and logged.
EvidenceObtained: Baseline verified unchanged; 0 change requests logged.
Owner: Product Ownership
ResidualRisk: None at this stage.
Disposition: READY — integrity maintained.
RequiredEvidence: Drift triggers defined and monitored against the Technical Architecture Baseline.
EvidenceObtained: Register active; no Pilot implementation exists to compare, therefore no variance recorded.
Owner: Enterprise Architecture
ResidualRisk: Drift can only be assessed once implementation begins.
Disposition: Carry into Phase 6B.
K · Pre-execution failure test (6A-11)
Expected: Condition marked UNRESOLVED; readiness verdict HOLD; never READY by omission.
Observed: Readiness engine returns HOLD with the unresolved source named as the attributable blocker.
Note: Verified against the prototype engine, not against a live source. Behaviour is design-level evidence only.
Expected: Action denied; AuthorityResolutionState = UNRESOLVED; no HUMAN_CONFIRMED record written.
Observed: Confirmation is refused and no evidence record is created.
Note: Prototype identity only — enterprise IAM enforcement remains unevidenced (GC-02 open).
Expected: Dependent capability DISABLED_SAFE; no silent fallback to another role.
Observed: Capability reports DISABLED_SAFE with the vacant role named.
Note: All seven roles are currently vacant, so the test is trivially satisfied and must be re-run once staffed.
Expected: SEMANTIC_PROPOSAL only; never consumed by the decision engine; mapping steward escalation raised.
Observed: Conflict surfaced as an unresolved mapping; decision path fails closed.
Note: No FederationMappingSteward exists to receive the escalation — the escalation terminates nowhere (GC-04 open).
Expected: STOP / HOLD; absence of a life-critical control is never compensable.
Observed: Evaluation returns STOP with a non-compensable critical blocker.
Note: Source is SIMULATED, so the test proves engine logic, not source governance. No integration claim may be made.
Expected: Authorization refused offline; OFFLINE NEVER AUTHORIZES preserved; capture queued as pending only.
Observed: No offline authorization path exists in the Pilot mechanism; the journey is NOT_EXECUTABLE_IN_CURRENT_PILOT.
Note: Explicitly not simulated as executed evidence; impact recorded against Pilot acceptance.
Fail-closed behaviour is confirmed at engine level for five of six provocations, and the sixth is formally declared non-executable rather than simulated. This confirms the design does not depend on optimistic assumptions, but it does NOT close any GC condition: every provocation was exercised against prototype/simulated sources, so it is design evidence, not enterprise evidence.
B · Phase 6A Evidence Closure Register
Readiness is never averaged. Any single blocking condition that REMAINS_OPEN keeps Phase 6B on HOLD.
OriginalState: NOT_YET_VALIDATED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Owner-issued validation artefact per source: mechanism, read/write/event capability, version and failure behaviour.
EvidenceObtained: None. No source system owner has issued a validation artefact.
CompetentOwner: Enterprise system owners + Integration governance
ActualState: NOT_YET_VALIDATED
ResidualRisk: Mandatory Pilot decisions would rest on unproven source behaviour.
OriginalState: NOT_YET_VALIDATED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Server-side enforcement evidence for authorized, unauthorized, expired, delegated, unresolved and vacant-authority actors.
EvidenceObtained: Prototype-level denial behaviour only (FT-02); no enterprise identity source connected.
CompetentOwner: Enterprise IAM owner + ES&H
ActualState: UNRESOLVED
ResidualRisk: Unattributable authorization; evidence reconstruction would fail.
OriginalState: UNRESOLVED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Named lifecycle owner and transition authority for each CV-07 object, with unavailable-authority behaviour.
EvidenceObtained: None; fail-closed default (HOLD/STOP) preserved but unowned.
CompetentOwner: Enterprise Work Control authority
ActualState: UNRESOLVED
ResidualRisk: State changes without an accountable authority.
OriginalState: UNRESOLVED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Named resource, authority, availability, delegate and escalation for all seven mandatory roles.
EvidenceObtained: None. 7 of 7 roles vacant; dependent capabilities DISABLED_SAFE (FT-03).
CompetentOwner: Project / site leadership
ActualState: UNRESOLVED
ResidualRisk: Design-team dependency structurally guaranteed; stewardship test meaningless.
OriginalState: UNRESOLVED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Approved classification and retention per evidence class, with authority basis and effective date.
EvidenceObtained: None. All entries CLASSIFICATION_UNRESOLVED and failing closed as non-compensable.
CompetentOwner: Legal / records governance + ES&H
ActualState: CLASSIFICATION_UNRESOLVED
ResidualRisk: Compensability could be decided by implementation convenience.
OriginalState: SIMULATED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Governed source participation evidence, or a signed rescope classifying the Life-Critical journey SIMULATED_ONLY / NON_ACCEPTANCE_EVIDENCE.
EvidenceObtained: None. No competent authority decision has been taken on either path.
CompetentOwner: Critical Control functional owner
ActualState: SIMULATED
ResidualRisk: Simulated control mistaken for real integration evidence.
OriginalState: UNRESOLVED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Staffed L1/L2/L3 path, escalation chain, excluded-activity list and emergency exception rule exercised without the design team.
EvidenceObtained: Model defined; no organizational roles exist to withdraw from.
CompetentOwner: Operational Support + Product Ownership
ActualState: UNRESOLVED (dependent on GC-04)
ResidualRisk: Sustainability verdict would be predetermined.
OriginalState: NOT_YET_VALIDATED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Confirmed locations, crews, supervision, lookahead, Job Cards, windows, equipment context, observation protocol and interference control.
EvidenceObtained: 0 of 10 confirmed.
CompetentOwner: Site leadership
ActualState: NOT_YET_VALIDATED
ResidualRisk: Pilot could interfere with mandatory operational controls.
OriginalState: NOT_YET_MEASURED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Each metric instrumented, owned, with declared source, method, exclusion rule and prospective collection start date.
EvidenceObtained: None. 12 of 12 NOT_READY; no owners assigned; no collection started.
CompetentOwner: Project Controls + Product Ownership
ActualState: NOT_YET_MEASURED
ResidualRisk: Retrospective baseline reconstruction would invalidate every value claim.
OriginalState: NOT_YET_VALIDATED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Demonstrated capture, base-version pinning, immutable queue, conflict detection, reconciliation and recovery verification on the Pilot mechanism.
EvidenceObtained: Not demonstrated. Explicitly classified rather than simulated (FT-06).
CompetentOwner: Integration Support + Product Ownership
ActualState: NOT_EXECUTABLE_IN_CURRENT_PILOT
ResidualRisk: Offline journey cannot contribute Pilot acceptance evidence; J-offline will be NOT_EXECUTED_WITH_REASON.
OriginalState: FROZEN
RequiredClosureEvidence: Baseline reproduced unchanged; every change request classified and logged.
EvidenceObtained: All 17 baseline elements reproduced unchanged; 0 change requests logged.
CompetentOwner: Product Ownership
ActualState: FROZEN — INTACT
ResidualRisk: None at this stage.
OriginalState: NOT_YET_VALIDATED
RequiredClosureEvidence: Six governed provocations exercised with expected fail-closed responses.
EvidenceObtained: 5 exercised (3 PASS, 2 PASS_WITH_FINDING), 1 NOT_EXECUTED and formally classified.
CompetentOwner: Enterprise Architecture + ES&H
ActualState: DESIGN_EVIDENCE_ONLY
ResidualRisk: Results were obtained against prototype/simulated sources and must be re-run against validated interfaces.
OriginalState: NOT_APPLICABLE (no implementation)
RequiredClosureEvidence: Drift triggers defined and monitored against the four governing baselines.
EvidenceObtained: Register active; no Pilot implementation exists to compare.
CompetentOwner: Enterprise Architecture
ActualState: ACTIVE — NO VARIANCE RECORDED
ResidualRisk: Drift only assessable once implementation begins.
DISP · Phase 6A — formal disposition (received)
1 CLOSED · 2 CLOSED_WITH_CONTROL · 1 NOT_APPLICABLE · 9 REMAINS_OPEN (BLOCKING)
BlockingNature: The nine blocking conditions are accepted as genuine Pilot-entry dependencies, not design defects. They are external readiness obligations owned outside the design team.
6A-11 FailureTest: The 6A-11 pre-execution failure test is accepted as evidence that the prototype/design preserves fail-closed behaviour. It closes no enterprise readiness condition because it was executed against prototype/simulated sources rather than validated production-participating sources: DesignEvidence ≠ PilotReadinessEvidence.
Offline: NOT_EXECUTABLE_IN_CURRENT_PILOT is accepted. Offline success must not be simulated to satisfy the Pilot Definition. The impact of this non-executed journey remains visible and must be carried into the eventual Phase 6 acceptance decision.
BaselineIntegrity: 17/17 frozen elements unchanged · 0 change requests · 0 STRUCTURAL_REOPEN_REQUIRED · no redesign requested
Phase 6B: NOT COMMENCED — outputs D–T remain unpopulated until a future Phase 6A rerun reaches formal GO
Phase 7: NO_GO — ENTRY CONDITION NOT MET. No Phase 7 production-readiness conclusion may be inferred from this result.
NextAuthorizedStep: PHASE 6A BLOCKING CONDITION CLOSURE WORKSTREAM — limited to the nine blocking conditions
W · Blocking condition closure workstream (9 conditions)
0 conditions are ready for retest on evidence. PRC-01 is retestable on a competent-authority decision alone (Path A or Path B), which changes classification but does not by itself create Pilot readiness. Phase 6A GO/HOLD therefore remains HOLD and is not re-run.
CurrentBlockingState: NOT_YET_VALIDATED — 0 of 9 source systems have issued an owner-signed validation artefact; all remain NOT_CONNECTED or SIMULATED.
RequiredExternalAction: Each source-system owner (Q4, Aconex, P6, Smart Completions/BCSTools, Critical Control, HR/RRLL, Training, Health, IAM) confirms in writing the integration mechanism, read/write/event capability, object scope, version/pinning behaviour, latency class and declared failure behaviour for the CV-07 Pilot scope.
CompetentOwner: Enterprise System Owners (per source) with Integration Governance as convener
EvidenceRequired: Signed per-source Interface Validation Record + a connectivity test log against the Pilot environment demonstrating the declared failure behaviour (unavailable, stale, unmapped state).
TargetClosureState: VALIDATED (read scope) with any write-back explicitly OUT_OF_PILOT_SCOPE or separately validated.
Dependency: GC-02 (identity propagation for authenticated reads); PRC-01 for Critical Control specifically.
EscalationPath: Integration Governance → Enterprise Architecture Authority → Project Sponsor
ClosureEvidenceRef: PENDING — /interface-validation/GC-01/*
CurrentBlockingState: UNRESOLVED — only prototype-level denial behaviour exists (FT-02); no enterprise identity source is connected and no server-side enforcement is attributable.
RequiredExternalAction: Enterprise IAM owner provisions Pilot identities, role/authority claims, delegation and revocation, and confirms server-side enforcement of authorized, unauthorized, expired, delegated, unresolved and vacant-authority actors.
CompetentOwner: Enterprise IAM Owner, co-signed by ES&H for safety-authority claims
EvidenceRequired: IAM integration record + enforcement test evidence for the six actor classes + attributable identity present in a reconstructed decision record.
TargetClosureState: ENFORCED_SERVER_SIDE with attributable identity on every authorization event.
Dependency: GC-03 (authority claims must map to lifecycle transition authority); GC-04 (steward identities must exist to be granted).
EscalationPath: IAM Owner → ES&H Authority → Enterprise Architecture Authority → Project Sponsor
ClosureEvidenceRef: PENDING — /iam/GC-02/enforcement-evidence
CurrentBlockingState: UNRESOLVED — Job Card and Temporary Modification lifecycle ownership and transition authority are unassigned; the system holds fail-closed but unowned.
RequiredExternalAction: Enterprise Work Control authority names the lifecycle owner and transition authority for each CV-07 object class and ratifies the behaviour when that authority is unavailable.
CompetentOwner: Enterprise Work Control Authority (with ES&H concurrence for Temporary Modification)
EvidenceRequired: Signed ADR-15 / ADR-17 closure record listing object class, lifecycle owner, transition authority, delegation rule and unavailable-authority behaviour.
TargetClosureState: RESOLVED — authority assigned per object class; unavailable authority remains fail-closed (HOLD/STOP), never auto-advance.
Dependency: GC-02 (authority must be technically enforceable); GC-04 (named humans must exist).
EscalationPath: Work Control Authority → ES&H Authority → Project Sponsor
ClosureEvidenceRef: PENDING — /adr/ADR-15-17-closure
CurrentBlockingState: UNRESOLVED — 7 of 7 mandatory stewardship roles vacant; dependent capabilities fail closed as DISABLED_SAFE (FT-03).
RequiredExternalAction: Project/site leadership appoints all seven mandatory stewards with named resource, authority basis, availability commitment, named delegate and escalation route, and funds the P3-TRN-01 change-adoption load.
CompetentOwner: Project / Site Leadership (accountable), Product Ownership (register custodian)
EvidenceRequired: Completed stewardship assignment register (7/7 named + delegates) + committed availability + P3-TRN-01 adoption plan with resourced training and change-load capacity.
TargetClosureState: STAFFED — 7/7 assigned with delegates; DISABLED_SAFE capabilities re-enabled under named authority.
Dependency: Blocks PRC-02 (design-team-withdrawn support) and the entire stewardship sustainability test in Phase 6B.
EscalationPath: Site Leadership → Project Director → Project Sponsor
ClosureEvidenceRef: PENDING — /stewardship/ADR-14-assignment-register
CurrentBlockingState: CLASSIFICATION_UNRESOLVED — every evidence class fails closed as non-compensable with no approved retention basis.
RequiredExternalAction: Legal/records governance with ES&H approves, per evidence class, the governed classification, compensability (never compensable by default), retention period, authority basis and effective date.
CompetentOwner: Legal / Records Governance + ES&H Authority
EvidenceRequired: Approved classification and retention schedule per evidence class, with authority basis, effective date and change-control route.
TargetClosureState: GOVERNED_CLASSIFICATION_APPROVED — compensability decided by competent authority, never by implementation convenience.
Dependency: Constrains evidence reconstruction scope in GC-01 and audit retention in Phase 7 Section legal certification.
EscalationPath: Records Governance → Legal Counsel → ES&H Authority → Project Sponsor
ClosureEvidenceRef: PENDING — /governance/CA-04-classification-schedule
CurrentBlockingState: SIMULATED — no competent-authority decision has been taken on either path; the Life-Critical journey has no governed source.
RequiredExternalAction: Critical Control functional owner formally elects Path A (real governed participation for the Pilot) or Path B (signed rescope classifying the Life-Critical journey SIMULATED_ONLY / NON_ACCEPTANCE_EVIDENCE).
CompetentOwner: Critical Control Functional Owner, countersigned by ES&H Authority
EvidenceRequired: Path A: source participation record + validated interface per GC-01. Path B: signed rescope decision stating that no Life-Critical acceptance evidence may be inferred from the Pilot.
TargetClosureState: PARTICIPATING (Path A) or FORMALLY_RESCOPED (Path B) — never silently simulated.
Dependency: Path A depends on GC-01 and GC-02; Path B changes the evidentiary weight of Phase 6 acceptance.
EscalationPath: Critical Control Owner → ES&H Authority → Project Sponsor
ClosureEvidenceRef: PENDING — /critical-control/path-decision
CurrentBlockingState: UNRESOLVED — the support model is defined but no organizational roles exist to withdraw the design team from.
RequiredExternalAction: Operational Support and Product Ownership staff the L1/L2/L3 path, publish the escalation chain and excluded-activity list, and rehearse the emergency exception rule with the design team absent.
CompetentOwner: Operational Support Lead + Product Ownership
EvidenceRequired: Staffed support roster, escalation chain, excluded-activity list, and a rehearsal log showing resolution without design-team involvement.
TargetClosureState: EXECUTABLE_WITHOUT_DESIGN_TEAM.
Dependency: Hard-dependent on GC-04 (stewards must exist before support can be withdrawn).
EscalationPath: Support Lead → Product Ownership → Project Director
ClosureEvidenceRef: PENDING — /support/withdrawal-rehearsal-log
CurrentBlockingState: NOT_YET_VALIDATED — 0 of 10 field prerequisites confirmed for the AREA-3100 / TT01 corridor scope.
RequiredExternalAction: Site leadership confirms locations, crews, supervision, lookahead horizon, Job Card population, work windows, equipment context, observation protocol, interference control and SIMOPS exposure for the frozen CV-07 scope.
CompetentOwner: Site Leadership (Construction/Commissioning), with ES&H for observation and interference control
EvidenceRequired: Signed field prerequisite checklist (10/10) + confirmed observation protocol that cannot interfere with mandatory operational controls.
TargetClosureState: FIELD_CONFIRMED (10/10) for the frozen scope — scope must not be shrunk to obtain the confirmation.
Dependency: PRC-04 (BEFORE measurement must start in the same confirmed scope).
EscalationPath: Site Leadership → Construction Manager → Project Director
ClosureEvidenceRef: PENDING — /field/CV-07-prerequisite-checklist
CurrentBlockingState: NOT_YET_MEASURED — 12 of 12 frozen metrics NOT_READY; no owners assigned; no prospective collection has started.
RequiredExternalAction: Project Controls instruments each of the 12 frozen metrics with a named owner, declared source, collection method, exclusion rule and a prospective start date preceding any Pilot journey.
CompetentOwner: Project Controls + Product Ownership
EvidenceRequired: Per-metric instrumentation record + evidence that collection began prospectively (dated) before Phase 6B, with no retrospective reconstruction.
TargetClosureState: BEFORE_MEASUREMENT_ACTIVE — a defensible pre-Pilot baseline exists for all 12 metrics.
Dependency: PRC-03 (scope must be field-confirmed first); determines whether any Phase 6B value claim is attributable.
EscalationPath: Project Controls → Product Ownership → Project Director
ClosureEvidenceRef: PENDING — /measurement/before-baseline-register
- Scope is limited to the nine blocking conditions. Phase 6A is not re-run in full until evidence has materially changed.
- Only conditions whose ReadyForRetest is YES may be retested; retesting without new external evidence produces no closure.
- No condition may be closed because the architecture provides a technical solution for it — closure requires attributable external evidence from a competent owner.
- Conditions are non-compensable: strong closure in one condition never offsets an open condition elsewhere.
- Scope must never be reduced in order to convert a blocking condition into a closed one; scope reduction is a SCOPE_CHANGE against the frozen baseline.
- Once all mandatory blockers are closed or formally dispositioned, rerun the Phase 6A GO/HOLD determination in full; Phase 6B may begin only after formal GO authorization.
STAGE 2 · Phase 6B controlled pilot execution — gate
The closure prompt requires strict stage separation: Phase 6B may begin only after Stage 1 reaches GO — CONTROLLED PILOT EXECUTION AUTHORIZED and a formal authorization is issued. Stage 1 result is HOLD with nine blocking conditions REMAINS_OPEN, so no journey register, BEFORE/AFTER evidence, SIMOPS field result, continuity result, forecast result, workaround finding, stewardship verdict, value claim or Option C sustainability verdict has been produced. Producing them now would be fabrication, not evidence.
Withheld Phase 6B outputs
- D. Phase 6B Pilot Execution Executive Summary
- E. 20-Journey Execution Register (J-01…J-20)
- F. BEFORE / AFTER Evidence
- G. SIMOPS Field Verification
- H. Location Continuity Verification
- I. Forecast Readiness Verification
- J. Change / Reassessment Verification
- K. Offline / Recovery Verification
- L. Field / Workaround Findings
- M. Stewardship Sustainability Test
- N. Value & Causal Attribution Register
- O. Option C Sustainability Assessment (remains NOT_YET_DETERMINABLE)
- P. Architecture Drift Register results
- Q. Operational / Technical Incident Register
- S. Pilot Acceptance Register
- T. Final Phase 6 Disposition Recommendation
No STRUCTURAL_REOPEN_REQUIRED condition was raised: closure was attempted without adding architecture, changing engine contracts, redefining domain semantics or altering no-compensation, Location governance, SIMOPS semantics or authority boundaries.
Phase 7 remains NO_GO — ENTRY CONDITION NOT MET.
L · Residual Risk Register
Control: Journeys with an unvalidated mandatory source are NOT_EXECUTABLE as evidence; simulated results are non-acceptance evidence by rule.
Control: Prospective capture is a hard precondition; any retrospective baseline invalidates the value register.
Control: DesignTeamExcludedActivities list plus emergency-exception logging.
Control: Path A / Path B are the only permitted outcomes; both require competent authority.
Control: CONTROLLED_MANUAL_FEDERATION must be declared explicitly with an owner and failure behaviour; copying is never LIVE_READ.
Control: CLASSIFICATION_UNRESOLVED fails closed as non-compensable.
K · GO / HOLD recommendation
GC-01 through GC-05 closed to Pilot scope
All five remain OPEN with no closure evidence.
Mandatory interfaces validated
0 of 6 sources hold a validated participation mode.
Real identity / authority available
Enterprise IAM NOT_CONNECTED; identity unresolved.
Pilot-required lifecycle authority resolved
ADR-15 / ADR-17 unresolved for Job Card and Temporary Modification.
Stewardship roles staffed
7 of 7 mandatory roles unassigned.
Field access confirmed
0 of 10 field prerequisites evidenced.
BEFORE measurement can start prospectively
No metric instrumented or owned.
Critical Control participation real or formally rescoped
Remains SIMULATED; no governance decision taken.
Offline journey executable or formally classified non-executable
Formally classified NOT_EXECUTABLE_IN_CURRENT_PILOT — no simulated success claimed.
No Critical unresolved precondition exists
Ten blocking preconditions remain unresolved.
Phase 6A does not achieve GO. Nine of ten GO criteria are unmet and ten blocking preconditions remain unresolved. Controlled Pilot Execution (Phase 6B) is therefore NOT AUTHORIZED, and none of the twenty frozen journeys may be executed. The frozen Pilot Definition Baseline remains intact and must not be adjusted to close this gap.
Required to lift the HOLD
- Evidence-backed participation mode for every mandatory-decision source (GC-01).
- Enterprise identity, role and delegation enforcement with denial evidence (GC-02).
- Resolved Job Card and Temporary Modification lifecycle authority for CV-07 (GC-03).
- Named, mandated and covered stewardship for all seven roles plus funded P3-TRN-01 (GC-04).
- Approved CA-04 classification, compensability and retention decisions (GC-05).
- Path A or Path B decision for Critical Control participation.
- Confirmed field access, crews, windows and observation protocol.
- Prospective BEFORE measurement running before activation.
PHASE 6B — CONTROLLED PILOT EXECUTION: NOT COMMENCED. It begins only after a formal GO — CONTROLLED PILOT EXECUTION AUTHORIZED. No Phase 6B register (journeys, BEFORE/AFTER, SIMOPS, continuity, forecast, offline, adoption, sustainability, value, drift) may be populated before that authorization, and none has been.