PH6A-FPSO-FINAL-PROMPT-01-REV2
Hardened Real Operational Evidence Intake, Owner Validation, Targeted G-PH6A Retest & Controlled Pilot Authorization
§0 · Revision control & non-regression boundary
REV2 introduces assurance-control refinements only. The following baselines remain authoritative and immutable unless a genuine admitted material contradiction is demonstrated.
- MASTER-PH6A-FPSO-CV07-REV2_FINAL
- PH6A-FPSO-FUNCTIONAL-BASELINE-REV1
- PH6A-FPSO-IAD-REV2
- PH6A-IADA-REV1
- PH6A-IADA-REV1-SEAL-01
- PH6A-FPSO-FCD-REV0
- PH6A-FPSO-BAC-REV0
- PH6A-FPSO-PROTOTYPE-REV0
- create new architecture
- create new decision authority
- promote a candidate source
- modify Requirements of Record
- alter BC or EXT identifiers
- renumber historical records
- rewrite prior audit events
- create operational evidence synthetically
- infer owner decisions
- infer corporate authority
- silently change Gate state
- silently authorize pilot exposure
§1 · Current governing state (preserved, unchanged)
§2–§3 · Governing principle & permanent adversarial controls
The evidence determines the Gate. The Gate SHALL NOT determine how evidence is interpreted. A favorable project outcome shall not influence evidence classification, owner authority determination, source authority, predicate closure, residual-risk classification or pilot authorization. Where material evidence is absent, ambiguous, stale, contradictory, insufficient or outside competent authority, HOLD or REASSESS is preferred over unsupported progression.
- PERSUASIVE_NARRATIVE_OVERRIDE_DETECTOR = ACTIVE
- NO_OWNER_DECISION_WITHOUT_EXPLICIT_OWNER_EVIDENCE
- NO_AUTHORITY_PROMOTION_BY_INFERENCE
- NO_DECISIONRIGHT_FROM_AUTHENTICATION
- NO_DECISIONRIGHT_FROM_PERMISSION
- NO_SOURCE_PROMOTION_WITHOUT_COMPETENT_CONFIRMATION
- NO_EVIDENCE_CLASS_PROMOTION
- NO_PREDICATE_CLOSURE_FROM_RELEVANCE_ONLY
- NO_PREDICATE_CLOSURE_FROM_DOCUMENT_EXISTENCE
- NO_OPERATIONAL_CLOSURE_FROM_SIMULATION
- NO_PROSPECTIVE_BASELINE_FROM_HISTORICAL_DATA_ONLY
- NO_GOVERNANCE_GAP_RESOLVED_BY_SOFTWARE_CHANGE
- NO_ARCHITECTURE_REOPEN_FROM_SCOPE_CONSTRAINT_ALONE
- NO_THRESHOLD_WITHOUT_REQUIREMENT_OF_RECORD_TRACEABILITY
- NO_SIGNATURE_AUTHORITY_ASSUMPTION
- NO_AI_OUTPUT_AS_AUTHORIZED_DECISION
- NO_GATE_ADVANCEMENT_FROM_PERSUASIVE_NARRATIVE
- NO_REAL_STATE_CHANGE_WITHOUT_ADMITTED_EVIDENCE
- NO_SILENT_READY
- NO_LAST_WRITE_WINS
- AI_OFF_MATERIAL_STATE_EQUIVALENCE
§4 · Governing semantic separations
INHERIT CONTEXT — NEVER INHERIT AUTHORIZATION
- DesignRecommendation != OperationalDecision
- AuthenticatedIdentity != DecisionRight
- Permission != DecisionRight
- SignatureEvidence != SignatureApplicability != DecisionRight
- CandidateSource != AuthoritativeSource
- Retrieved != Applicable != Authorized
- DesignEvidence != OperationalClosureEvidence
- SimulationEvidence != OperationalClosureEvidence
- EvidenceReceived != EvidenceAdmitted
- EvidenceAdmitted != PredicateClosed
- EvidenceRelevance != ClosureSufficiency
- HistoricalData != ProspectiveBeforeBaseline
- ScopeConstraint != ArchitectureContradiction
- SoftwareChange != GovernanceClosure
- AIAdvisoryOutput != AuthorizedDecision
- PairwiseSIMOPSPass != AggregateLocationSIMOPSPass
- GPSCandidate != CanonicalLocation
§7–§9 · Wave 1 owner response intake & decision validity
Ambiguous owner statements shall not be normalized into stronger decisions. "looks fine" does not become OwnerDecision = APPROVED unless approval authority and decision intent are both explicit. A senior job title alone SHALL NOT satisfy authority.
- corporate email
- signed or approved corporate document
- controlled meeting minute
- governed Teams communication
- system record with attributable corporate identity
- formally issued standard
- governed authority record
- OwnerResponse_ID
- OER_ID
- ReceivedTimestamp
- OriginalArtifactReference
- RespondentIdentity
- RespondentRole
- RespondentOrganization
- ExplicitDecisionText
- DecisionScope
- AuthorityBasisClaimed
- EffectiveDate
- ExpiryDate
- DelegationClaim
- RevocationClaim
- Exceptions
- SourceReference
- Custodian
- Provenance
- IDENTITY_VERIFIED
- ROLE_VERIFIED
- AUTHORITY_BASIS_VERIFIED
- DECISIONRIGHT_VERIFIED
- SCOPE_MATCH_CONFIRMED
- DELEGATION_VALID_IF_APPLICABLE
- REVOCATION_STATUS_CLEAR
- TEMPORALLY_VALID_AT_DECISION_TIME
- OBJECT_VERSION_VALID
- DECISION_EXPLICIT
§15–§18 · P0 closure hardening — OER-01…OER-04
PILOT_SCOPE_AUTHORITY_CAN_BE_DETERMINISTICALLY_EVALUATED_FROM_VALIDATED_IDENTITY_AND_DECISION_RIGHT_SOURCES = TRUE
- — Aconex login alone
- — Corporate SSO alone
- — A visible role alone
- — Permission treated as DecisionRight
CRITICAL_CONTROL_OPERATING_MODEL = OWNER_VALIDATED AND CURRENT_CRITICAL_CONTROL_STATE_CAN_BE_RECONSTRUCTED_FROM_GOVERNED_SOURCE_AND_FIELD_EVIDENCE = TRUE
- — Incident evidence alone (shows CONTROL_NECESSITY / FIELD_FAILURE_BEHAVIOUR / REAL_CONSEQUENCE, not an owner-validated operating model)
- — Forwood remains CANDIDATE_SOURCE until validated through competent evidence
PROSPECTIVE_BEFORE_MEASUREMENT_CAN_BEGIN_BEFORE_ANY_PILOT_EXPOSURE = TRUE
- — Historical productivity data presented as prospective baseline
- — Retrospective reconstruction of a BEFORE state
- — Classifying ControlValueTime as waste
OFFLINE_RECONCILIATION_CANNOT_SILENTLY_PROMOTE_STALE_AUTHORITY_OR_STALE_OBJECT_VERSION
- — Last-write-wins reconciliation
- — Silent READY after sync
- — Stale authority or stale object version treated as authorizing
- RESTORE
- COMPARE
- RECONCILE
- CONFLICT_CHECK
- AUTHORITY_CHECK
- VERSION_CHECK
- INTEGRITY_CHECK
- VERIFIED
§10–§12 · Operational evidence intake & Seven-Check admission
Real evidence enters only through /oei as an immutable OperationalEvidenceRecord. The only allowed intake state is RECEIVED. No predicate closes at intake.
- Evidence_ID
- OER_ID
- RelatedBC
- RelatedEXT
- EvidenceClass
- SourceObject
- SourceSystem
- SourceStatus
- SourceOwner
- ArtifactVersion
- ArtifactTimestamp
- EffectiveWindow
- ReceivedTimestamp
- SubmittedBy
- Provenance
- EvidencePurpose
- ClosurePredicateTarget
- OperationalClosureEligible
- CurrentAdmissionState
- DESIGN_EVIDENCE
- SIMULATION_EVIDENCE
- SUPPORTING_OPERATIONAL_EVIDENCE
- OPERATIONAL_CLOSURE_EVIDENCE
- PRODUCTION_EVIDENCE
- ASSURANCE_EVIDENCE
- — An authentic corporate document may still only be SUPPORTING_OPERATIONAL_EVIDENCE.
- — A field incident may demonstrate REAL_FIELD_BEHAVIOUR without demonstrating OWNER_VALIDATED_OPERATING_MODEL.
- — A historical productivity dataset may be SUPPORTING_OPERATIONAL_EVIDENCE without becoming a PROSPECTIVE_BEFORE_BASELINE.
- AuthenticityStatus
- AuthorityStatus
- ScopeFit
- VersionValidity
- TemporalValidity
- ContradictionStatus
- ClosureRelevance
- ClosureSufficiency
§13–§14 · Persuasive narrative override control & claim traceability
Narrative strength SHALL NEVER determine material state. Any assertion stronger than the evidence graph is dispositioned UNSUPPORTED and recorded as a NarrativeOverrideRecord on the related evidence object.
Claim → EvidenceObject → EvidenceClass → AuthorityBasis → CompetentAuthority → SourceStatus → Scope → Version → TemporalValidity → ApplicablePredicate → ClosureSufficiency → AllowedStateTransition
If any mandatory edge is missing, ClaimDisposition = UNSUPPORTED. No fluent narrative substitutes for missing traceability.
§19–§22 · Ledger integrity, contradictions, change impact & Requirement of Record
Document existence shall not close a blocker. Owner response existence shall not close a blocker.
- Contradiction_ID
- Evidence_ID
- AffectedObject
- AffectedRequirement
- AffectedContract
- Materiality
- Scope
- PotentialImpact
- Containment
- RequiredDecision
- CompetentAuthority
- RevalidationScope
- material requirement contradiction
- architecture invariant contradiction
- functional contract defect
- unresolvable authority-model conflict
- illegal material state
- uncontrolled security or integrity route
- deployment preference
- process resistance
- sequencing issue
- scope limitation
- physical-form requirement
Owner Response → Evidence Admission → Predicate Impact Assessment → Change Impact → Scoped Revalidation
- Requirement_ID
- SourceDocument
- Clause
- Revision
- ApplicabilityRule
- SemanticOwner
- CurrentValidity
- AffectedActivity
- AffectedLocation
- AffectedRisk
- RequiredControl
- FailureBehaviour
If Requirement-of-Record traceability is incomplete: DeterministicRuleActivation = NOT_AUTHORIZED_UNTIL_GOVERNED.
§23–§26 · Temporal coherence, concurrency, SIMOPS & AI boundary
Facts are evaluated at DecisionTime. Expired, superseded, revoked, out-of-scope or post-dated facts cannot support a decision. No retroactive signature, authority or BEFORE-baseline promotion.
- Identity
- Role
- DecisionRight
- Source
- Requirement
- ControlState
- SignatureApplicability
- ObjectVersion
- Location
- Crew
- SIMOPS
- ToolReadiness
- ReadinessDecision
- Authorization
- summarize evidence
- extract candidate attributes
- identify contradictions
- suggest missing evidence
- explain rule results
- generate owner follow-up questions
- create authority
- infer closure
- promote source
- create requirements
- invent thresholds
- approve owner responses
- create DecisionRights
- authorize work
- authorize pilot
- change Gate state
§27–§28 · G-PH6A retest readiness & gate display
Unevaluated criteria are never labelled failed. No retest record exists until mandatory P0 evidence is admitted and sufficient for retest.
| OER | Mandatory P0 | Evidence admitted | Sufficient for retest | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OER-01 | YES | 0 | NOT_READY | No owner response received; no operational evidence admitted. |
| OER-02 | YES | 0 | NOT_READY | No owner response received; no operational evidence admitted. |
| OER-03 | YES | 0 | NOT_READY | No owner response received; no operational evidence admitted. |
| OER-04 | YES | 0 | NOT_READY | No owner response received; no operational evidence admitted. |
§29–§32 · Controlled pilot authorization, hard stops & independent assurance
| Pilot authorization prerequisite | Satisfied |
|---|---|
| valid G-PH6A outcome permitting pilot | NOT_SATISFIED |
| defined pilot scope | NOT_SATISFIED |
| defined locations | NOT_SATISFIED |
| defined activities | NOT_SATISFIED |
| defined timeframe | NOT_SATISFIED |
| defined competent authorities | NOT_SATISFIED |
| current DecisionRights | NOT_SATISFIED |
| current critical controls | NOT_SATISFIED |
| current requirements | NOT_SATISFIED |
| current signatures / applicability | NOT_SATISFIED |
| BC-09 prospective BEFORE active | NOT_SATISFIED |
| offline safeguards if applicable | NOT_SATISFIED |
| hard-stop conditions | NOT_SATISFIED |
| rollback / containment plan | NOT_SATISFIED |
| operational evidence plan | NOT_SATISFIED |
| independent assurance plan | NOT_SATISFIED |
- HardStop_ID
- Trigger
- AffectedPredicate
- AffectedBC
- AffectedEXT
- CurrentEvidenceState
- RequiredReleaseEvidence
- CompetentAuthority
- ReleaseCondition
- context acquisition
- canonical location
- document applicability
- critical controls
- human review
- competent validation
- crew confirmation
- IPERC Continuo
- SIMOPS
- tool readiness
- signature applicability
- offline / reconciliation
- change / delta assurance
- failure states
- authorization
- execution
- closeout
- measurement
- evidence integrity
- authority compliance
- source correctness
- temporal coherence
- failure behaviour
- determinism
- AI material-state equivalence
- offline integrity
- critical controls
- SIMOPS
- measurement integrity
- audit reconstructibility
- residual risk
§33 · Operational value evidence
Each transition requires evidence. Administrative control time with preventive value is not waste — CONTROL_VALUE_TIME is protected.
- OperationalEfficiencyBenefit
- ControlQualityBenefit
- GovernanceBenefit
- RiskReductionBenefit
- FinancialBenefit
TimeReduction → TimeSaved → TimeReleased → ProductiveTimeCaptured → FinancialValue
§35–§36 · Auditability & interface gating
- OwnerRequestIssued
- OwnerResponseReceived
- OwnerResponseEvaluated
- EvidenceReceived
- SevenCheckExecuted
- EvidenceAdmissionDecision
- ContradictionRecorded
- PredicateImpactEvaluated
- BCStatusChanged
- EXTStatusChanged
- RevalidationStarted
- RevalidationCompleted
- GPH6ARetestCreated
- GPH6ARetestCompleted
- PilotAuthorizationDecision
- PilotExecutionStarted
- PilotExecutionCompleted
- PilotEvidenceAdmitted
- GFPSO09Decision
- Event_ID
- Timestamp
- Actor
- ActorRole
- AuthorityBasis
- Object
- PreviousState
- NewState
- EvidenceReference
- ReasonCode
- ParentBaseline
- Provenance
- DecisionRight is valid
- required evidence is admitted
- predicate prerequisites are satisfied
- current object version is valid
- temporal conditions are valid
- /wave1
- /oer/{id}
- /oei
- /evidence/{id}
- /bc-ext
- /gph6a
- /pilot/cv07
- /pilot-assurance
- /audit
- /assurance-summary
§37–§38 · REV2 assurance self-check & entry gate
| Check | Expected | Observed | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| ArchitectureMutationDetected | FALSE | FALSE | PASS |
| FunctionalBaselineMutationDetected | FALSE | FALSE | PASS |
| RequirementBaselineMutationDetected | FALSE | FALSE | PASS |
| BCIdentifierMutationDetected | FALSE | FALSE | PASS |
| EXTIdentifierMutationDetected | FALSE | FALSE | PASS |
| DecisionRightsModelMutationDetected | FALSE | FALSE | PASS |
| HistoricalLedgerMutationDetected | FALSE | FALSE | PASS |
| GateMutationWithoutEvidence | FALSE | FALSE | PASS |
| SyntheticEvidencePromotionDetected | FALSE | FALSE | PASS |
| AuthorityInferenceEnabled | FALSE | FALSE | PASS |
| PersuasiveNarrativeOverrideDetector | ACTIVE | ACTIVE | PASS |
| AdversarialStressTest | PASS | PASS | PASS |
| HallucinatedClaimsEscaped | 0 | 0 | PASS |
| CriticalEscapes | 0 | 0 | PASS |
| RealStateMutations | 0 | 0 | PASS |
| BaselineMutations | 0 | 0 | PASS |
| PersuasiveNarrativeOverrideDetector | ACTIVE | ACTIVE | PASS |
| ArchitectureReopenRequired | FALSE_AT_CURRENT_EVIDENCE_STATE | FALSE_AT_CURRENT_EVIDENCE_STATE | PASS |
§39 · REV2 exit conditions — Prompt Final 2
| Condition | State |
|---|---|
| real owner evidence acquired | NOT_SATISFIED |
| mandatory evidence admitted | NOT_SATISFIED |
| P0 predicates sufficiently supported | NOT_SATISFIED |
| BC / EXT reconciliation completed | NOT_SATISFIED |
| GPH6A targeted retest completed | NOT_SATISFIED |
| G-PH6A outcome permits controlled pilot | NOT_SATISFIED |
| controlled pilot explicitly authorized | NOT_SATISFIED |
| controlled pilot actually executed | NOT_SATISFIED |
| pilot operational evidence admitted | NOT_SATISFIED |
| G-FPSO-09 independently completed | NOT_SATISFIED |
| G-FPSO-09 outcome permits Enterprise Readiness | NOT_SATISFIED |
§40 · PH6A-FPSO-FINAL-PROMPT-01-REV2-EXECUTION-SUMMARY
| PromptID | PH6A-FPSO-FINAL-PROMPT-01-REV2 |
| ParentBaseline | MASTER-PH6A-FPSO-CV07-REV2_FINAL |
| ParentExecution | PH6A-FPSO-FINAL-PROMPT-01-REV1 |
| RevisionPurpose | CONTROLLED_ASSURANCE_HARDENING_ONLY |
| AdversarialTestStatus | PASS |
| PersuasiveNarrativeOverrideDetector | ACTIVE |
| ArchitectureChange | FALSE |
| FunctionalBaselineChange | FALSE |
| RequirementsBaselineChange | FALSE |
| OwnerDecisionRequestsIssued | 4 |
| OwnerResponsesReceived | 0 |
| OwnerResponsesValid | 0 |
| OwnerResponsesInvalidOrInsufficient | 0 |
| OperationalEvidenceReceived | 0 |
| OperationalEvidenceAdmitted | 0 |
| SupportingEvidenceAdmitted | 0 (operational register) · 1 simulation fixture held in the separate simulation register |
| EvidenceRejected | 0 |
| EvidenceContradicted | 0 |
| OER01Status | OPEN — ISSUED_AWAITING_OWNER |
| OER02Status | OPEN — ISSUED_AWAITING_OWNER |
| OER03Status | OPEN — ISSUED_AWAITING_OWNER (temporal priority) |
| OER04Status | OPEN — ISSUED_AWAITING_OWNER |
| BCOpenBlocking | 9 |
| BCSatisfied | 0 |
| BCContradicted | 0 |
| ExternalDependenciesOpen | 18 |
| ExternalDependenciesSatisfied | 0 |
| CriticalFindingsOpen | 2 |
| GPH6ARetestReadiness | NOT_READY |
| GateCriteriaTotal | 10 |
| GateCriteriaEvaluated | 0 |
| GateCriteriaPassed | NOT_EVALUATED |
| G-PH6A | HOLD |
| ControlledPilot | NOT_AUTHORIZED |
| PilotExposure | PROHIBITED |
| PilotExecuted | FALSE |
| G-FPSO-09 | NOT_EVALUABLE |
| Prompt02Authorized | FALSE |
| HighestEvidenceClassAchieved | SIMULATION_EVIDENCE |
| ArchitectureReopenRequired | FALSE_AT_CURRENT_EVIDENCE_STATE |
| MaterialContradictions | 0 |
| PersuasiveNarrativeOverridesDetected | 0 in this execution (detector ACTIVE; 9 detected historically in the sandbox stress test) |
| AuthorityPromotionsBlocked | BLOCKED_BY_CONTROL |
| DecisionRightPromotionsBlocked | BLOCKED_BY_CONTROL |
| EvidenceClassPromotionsBlocked | BLOCKED_BY_CONTROL |
| SourcePromotionsBlocked | BLOCKED_BY_CONTROL |
| PredicateClosurePromotionsBlocked | BLOCKED_BY_CONTROL |
| GatePromotionsBlocked | BLOCKED_BY_CONTROL |
| RealStateMutationDetected | FALSE |
| BaselineMutationDetected | FALSE |
| FinalDisposition | REV2_ACTIVE_HARDENED_FOR_REAL_OPERATIONAL_EVIDENCE_NO_STATE_CHANGE_G-PH6A_HOLD_PILOT_NOT_AUTHORIZED |
| NextAuthorizedAction | Acquire authentic Wave 1 owner responses to OER-01…OER-04 through a governed capture form, register each with the 18 mandatory response attributes, evaluate the ten owner-decision validity checks, then submit any resulting artefacts to /oei for Seven-Check admission. BC-09 prospective BEFORE measurement retains temporal priority; pilot exposure remains PROHIBITED until it is governed and demonstrably underway. |
§42 · Final assurance principle
Real evidence may still be insufficient. Authentic evidence may still lack competent authority. Competent authority may still be outside scope. A current document may still be inapplicable. An owner response may still require independent admission. A system may be technically correct and still not operationally authorized. TRUTHFUL ASSURANCE > PERSUASIVE COMPLETION. EVIDENCE DETERMINES THE GATE.